New Jersey finally prevails in the second overtime, advances to face Anchorage for NAHL title

Down three times in the second and third periods, the New Jersey Titans refused to die, and got a power play goal in the second overtime versus the New Mexico Ice Wolves to reach the NAHL title game.

New Mexico vs New Jersey; Game 3
New Jersey Titans players celebrated after a power play goal by Ryan Coughlin in the second overtime lifted them to a 4-3 win over the New Mexico Ice Wolves and sent the Titans to the Robertson Cup championship game on Sunday, May 22, 2022 at Fogarty Arena in Blaine, Minn.
Jeff Lawler / Courtesy NAHL

BLAINE, Minn. -- There is only one way to beat the New Jersey Titans in the playoffs it seems.

“If you’re going to beat us, you’ll have to kill us,” said Titans coach Craig Doremus. And with one game left in the NAHL season, the Titans are proving very hard to kill.

They were two minutes from seeing their season end on Sunday versus the New Mexico Ice Wolves, but prevailed with a power play goal in the second overtime, winning 4-3 to advance to the Robertson Cup title game.

New Jersey will face the expansion Anchorage Wolverines on Tuesday night at the Ice House in Blaine, with the winner hoisting the NAHL’s top trophy.

Brendan Dumas had a pair of goals for the Titans on Sunday, after they lost game one of the best-of-three series but prevailed in overtime on Saturday and in double overtime in the finale. Goalie Andrew Takacs, who is committed to Colgate, had 46 saves in the win.


As well as praising his team, Doremus had nothing but good things to say about the Ice Wolves and their coach, Phil Fox, after the effort over the three games.

“That’s an incredible hockey team … I want to tip my cap to them,” Doremus said. “I just told Phil he’s one of the classiest guys I’ve dealt with in all my years here and I’m a better coach today than I was three days ago when I started coaching against him.”

New Mexico vs New Jersey; Game 3
New Mexico Ice Wolves left winger Grant Ellings (10) carried the puck between New Jersey Titans defenders Colin Grable (3) and Eric Charpentier (20) in the first period of their Robertson Cup semifinal game on Sunday, May 22, 2022 at Fogarty Arena in Blaine, Minn.
Jeff Lawler / Courtesy NAHL

New Mexico took 1-0, 2-1 and 3-2 leads but could not get any separation, and they took four penalties in the two overtime periods, including a five-minute major that eventually led to the series-winning goal.

“Obviously it stings. You hate giving up one in the third like that with a buck-thirty left. That’s always hard,” said Fox, who was named the NAHL coach of the year. “You’ve got to be smart in overtime and you can’t be taking penalties.”

After a tight first period, the Ice Wolves opened the second with an exclamation point. While killing a penalty, Alex Gomez picked off a loose puck and sprung himself on a shorthanded breakaway. It ended with the lanky center shoveling the puck one-handed between the New Jersey goalie’s pads.

The Titans answered and tied the game on a Dumas shot that made it through a crowd and over the line. But New Mexico’s power play, which had struggled, finally clicked later in the second to give the Ice Wolves a 2-1 lead after 40 minutes.

New Mexico vs New Jersey; Game 3
New Mexico Ice Wolves defenseman Brandon Holt carried the puck in the second period of his team's Robertson Cup semifinal game versus the New Jersey Titans on Sunday, May 22, 2022 at Fogarty Arena in Blaine, Minn.
Jeff Lawler / Courtesy NAHL

After Dumas’ second goal of the game tied it 2-2 for the Titans, New Mexico defenseman Jack Dalton had a pretty individual rush to the net that was capped off with his first goal of the playoffs to put the Ice Wolves up 3-2. Dalton had been a late addition to the lineup after Ice Wolves defenseman Gustav Blom was injured in Saturday night’s overtime win by the Titans.

“I’ve got to give Jack all the credit in the world. He’s done that for us this year, time in and time out,” Fox said.


New Jersey pulled the goalie and managed an extra attacker goal with 90 seconds left in regulation to force overtime. The first extra session was a back-and-forth affair with both teams killing two penalties and both goalies standing strong.

Right winger Ryan Coughlin, who is committed to Mercyhurst, finally finished it in the second overtime. Their coach said that playing all of his players in the extra session may have kept them fresh.

“I’m the type of coach that I don’t overreact to any situation,” he said. “Despite being down or up, stick to what you believe.”

Ice Wolves goalie Beni Halasz finished with 37 saves in the loss.

New Jersey 4, New Mexico 3, 2OT

New Mexico 0-2-1-0-0—3

New Jersey 0-1-2-0-1—4

First period — No scoring. Penalties — William Howard, NM (roughing), 0:19; Anthony Mollica, NJ (roughing), 0:19; Owen Luik, NJ (slashing), 4:02; Dillan Bentley, NM (cross checking), 19:18.


Second period — 1. NM, Alex Gomez 2 (unassisted), 0:25, (sh). 2. NJ, Brendan Dumas 2 (Tommy Bannister), 6:07. 3. NM, Brandon Holt 1 (Howard), 13:12, (pp). Penalties — Bentley, NM (roughing), 1:58; Dumas, NJ (tripping), 12:26; Eric Charpentier, NJ (holding), 14:37.

All 29 NAHL teams will play in the Showcase from Sept. 14-17 at the Super Rink in Blaine, Minn.
The allegations were serious enough to forward to the United States Center for SafeSport, the North American Hockey League, USA Hockey and local authorities.
Over 30 players from Minnesota and North Dakota were selected in the 2022 NAHL draft
Several players were tendered earlier this week.
Numerous players from Minnesota, and two from North Dakota, have signed tenders with NAHL teams prior to the league's upcoming draft.
The New Jersey Titans looked anything but tired on Tuesday, holding off the Anchorage Wolverines and playing a perfect defensive game to claim their first NAHL title.
Overtime was a thriller for both teams as the New Jersey Titans got a stellar night in goal to stave off elimination, beating the New Mexico Ice Wolves to tie their NAHL semifinal series at 1-1.
Anchorage Wolverines coach Mike Aikens will take an expansion team into the Robertson Cup title game on Tuesday after his team beat the St. Cloud Norsemen Saturday to win their NAHL semifinal series.
A pair of early goals and a near-perfect night by their goalie moved the New Mexico Ice Wolves within two wins of the NAHL title in their first-ever Robertson Cup game on Friday.
It took nearly 50 saves by an Anchorage native to put the expansion Wolverines one win from a trip to the NAHL title game after they survived a first-round battle with St. Cloud.

Third period — 4. NJ, Dumas 3 (unassisted), 4:36. 5. NM, Jack Dalton 1 (Tony Leahy), 7:31. 6. NJ, Anthony Calafiore 3 (Nick Ring, David Posma), 18:30, (ea). Penalties — None.

Overtime 1 — No scoring. Penalties — Dumas, NJ (hooking), 3:17; Leahy, NM (tripping), 5:32; Nikolai Dulak NM (high sticking), 8:24; Chris Carroll, NJ (tripping), 12:19.

Overtime 2 — 7. NJ, Ryan Coughlin 6 (Bannister), 12:55, (pp). Penalties — Leahy, NM (holding), 6:12; Howard, NM (5-checking from behind, 10-misconduct), 9:46.

Shots on goal — NM 11-9-12-10-7—49; NJ 6-7-12-8-8—41. Goalies — Beni Halasz, NM (41 shots-37 saves); Andrew Takacs, NJ (49-46). Power plays — NM 1-of-6, NJ 1-of-8. Referees — Luke Gagnon, Austin O'Rourke. Linesmen — Ben Gawlik, Jacob Paugh. Att. — 1,022.

Jess Myers covers college hockey, as well as outdoors, general sports and travel, for The Rink Live and the Forum Communications family of publications. He came to FCC in 2018 after three decades of covering sports as a freelancer for a variety of publications, while working full time in politics and media relations. A native of Warroad, Minn. (the real Hockeytown USA), Myers has a degree in journalism/communications from the University of Minnesota Duluth. He lives in the Twin Cities. Contact Jess via email at, or find him on Twitter via @JessRMyers. English speaker.
What to read next